*
 

Referring to the August 2011 levy, the last “renewal” levy that was on the ballot as a conversion to a “continuing” (permanent) levy, Board members said the following:

Mark Dosen:  “The voters very clearly, I think, understood what we were trying to accomplish.”

Board President, David Tryon:  “There were a few people that did criticize that we moved from a periodic levy to a continuing levy last time.  I think it passed by 70%, the largest margin of anything ever, of a levy that’s passed in the community, the last time.”

Dosen:  “I think it was closer to 74%.”

Tryon: “Oh, 74%.  Well, that’s pretty convincing.”

Mark Jantzen:  “The community understands.”

That’s Scooby-Doobie-Doo-doo!

The last time the Board had a “renewal” levy on the ballot as a “continuing” levy was in August 2011.  That levy passed by 61% -- NOT 74%, as Mr. Dosen claimed! 

Also, that renewal levy passed by the LOWEST margin for renewal levies in 35 years!---NOT the “largest margin ever”, as Mr. Tryon claimed. 

The last time a renewal levy passed by a lower margin than the August 2011 levy was in 1978. See the truth for yourself.  Election results of all levies since 1957 (56 years) can be seen in the District’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR) that is filed with the Auditor of State.

This is just another example of the Board providing the public with false and/or misleading information when it wants to get a levy passed!

*************

Board member, Mark Dosen said that one reason the Board put the “renewal” levy on the ballot as a “continuing” forever levy is the following:

“…to stabilize our finances.”

That’s Scooby-Doobie-Doo-doo!

Renewal levies are NOT a threat to the financial stability of the District!  The Board’s irresponsible SPENDING is the reason its finances are “unstable”!  If the Board TRULY wanted to “stabilize our finances”, the Board would STOP SPENDING MORE MONEY THAN IT IS RECEIVING!  And, STOP APPROVING INCREASES THE BOARD CANNOT AFFORD!

Renewal levies have historically passed by wide margins.  The District’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR) that is filed with the State Auditor includes a record of election results since 1957 (56 years ago).  In the past 56 years, only TWO renewal levies failed (35 years ago and 52 years ago)!  Surely,  Mr. Dosen must already know that, which might explain why, only moments after talking about “stabilizing our finances”, said a reason the Board put the forever levy on the ballot was “to lock them in.”

That’s the truth!  The Board put the levy on the ballot as a forever levy "to lock them in"!  The Board doesn’t want the voters to ever have the ability to vote down a renewal levy—not 35 years from now, not 52 years from now, NOT EVER!

*************

In the video published on the District’s website, BBHCSD Treasurer, Richard Berdine said the following: 

“We learned in our community surveys and focus group discussions, the rising and huge costs of placing these renewals on the ballot is a concern to the community, as well as constantly being on the ballot year after year seeking renewals...”

On the District’s “Levy Information” page on the District’s website, the following statement is made:

“Voter fatigue is an issue in our community.  In Superintendent attended focus groups, residents voiced dissatisfaction with the number of times the district is on the ballot.  They expressed the need to reduce the number and costs of election issues.”

This is all SCOOBY-DOOBIE-DOO-DOO! 

The Board approved putting the renewal levy on the ballot as a “continuing” forever levy on January 7, 2013.  There was ONLY ONE focus group meeting prior to that January 7, 2013 meeting.  That focus group was comprised of people who were invited by the PSO Presidents of each school.  Since the PSO has historically supported school levies, and since the focus group was comprised of people invited by the PSO presidents, it is likely that this particular focus group was a group likely to support school levies.  Public records show that of the 91 people who made comments at that focus group meeting,
  • a total of ONE person suggested converting renewal levies to “continuing” levies
  • absolutely NO ONE said they were tired of voting on levies
  • absolutely NO ONE said anything about the cost of the levy being on the ballot!
Also, the last community survey that was done was in the Spring of 2011—after voters had recently rejected three “new money” levies in a row. There were more than 500 written responses to that survey—and the respondents had A LOT to say! (go)  Of the more than 500 responses:
  • a total ONE person simply commented on the number of times the Board is on the ballot “for a new or renewal” levy
  • TWO people said they are opposed to a permanent “continuing” levy (that’s twice as many as those from the focus group who said were in favor of a permanent levy)
  • ONE person said they wanted their taxes to go down and did not want their taxes to remain the same forever
  • NO ONE said the Board should convert a renewal levy into a “continuing” levy
  • NO ONE said they were tired of voting on levies
  • NO ONE said anything about the cost of putting levies on the ballot.

So, even though only ONE person said he/she favored changing a renewal levy to a continuing levy, and even though THREE people indicated they are opposed to a continuing levy, the Board is telling the public that the Board is putting the levy on the ballot as a “continuing” levy because responses from the focus groups and community survey show that the community is tired of voting on levies.

And, even though absolutely NO ONE in either the focus group or the Community Survey said anything, at all, about the cost of putting levies on the ballot, the Board is telling the public that, responses from the focus groups and Community Survey show that the community is concerned about the cost of putting levies on the ballot!

This is just another example of the Board giving the public false and/or misleading information at a time when it wants to get a levy passed!

Oh, and one more thing:  Even though the Board is talking about how converting the renewal levy to a “continuing” levy would save the District money--the District doesn’t even know how much each election costs!—or at least that’s what I was essentially told.  I made a public records request for all invoices, itemized statements, cancelled checks, and purchase orders for all election costs from FY07-present.  In response to my request, the Public Records Officer told me that none of those records exist!