Ms. Engelhart:
I have looked at your website and I disagree with some of your information. Unfortunately, when mentioning salaries you seem to leave out the fact that the average teacher salary you are quoting is one with a Master's Degree AND 13 years of experience. To me this is an important detail that you intentionally left out of your writing. What do you personally believe a person with a Bachelor's Degree, Master's Degree, and 13 years of experience should earn? What do you think an engineer would those credentials would earn? If you said more than twice that amount you would be right.
Another interesting bit of propaganda is your assertion that teachers will receive a salary increase of " a minimum of 10%." I firmly believe this is false. According to your numbers, a teacher earning $79,000 next year will be earning about $87,000 the following year. The year after, if this 10% increase continues, the salary would be $95,700. So to recap, the average teacher in the Brecksville-Broadview Heights School District will be earning close to $100,000 in two years. This is the message that you are sending to the community, and unfortunately the kids in this city will suffer because many people will believe your rhetoric.
Thank you for your time.
Regards, Tim Kenney
*************
Here is my response to the points you made in your letter:
When mentioning salaries you seem to leave out the fact that the average teacher salary you are quoting is one with a Master's Degree AND 13 years of experience. To me this is an important detail that you intentionally left out of your writing.
I did not intentionally leave out any important details in my letter. There are many, many details that can always be added to the mix in order to get a better understanding of any given statistic. We are limited in letters to the editor to only 350 words. My website does, in fact, show each teacher’s salary along with their education level and years of experience. If someone thinks that a Master’s Degree and 13 years of experience is an important detail that belongs in a letter to the editor, then it’s up to that person to write that letter. Someone else might then say that writer left out an important detail like there are xxx number of people who hold Master’s degrees with 13 years of experience who are currently unemployed. It would then be up to that person to bring out that particular detail, and so on..
What do you personally believe a person with a Bachelor's Degree, Master's Degree, and 13 years of experience should earn?
In the private sector, I think such a person should earn whatever the employer is willing to pay that person. In the public sector, when public officials are paying employees with other people’s money (tax dollars), the question is not “what SHOULD a person earn?” The question is what can we afford to pay?
What do you think an engineer (with) those credentials would earn? If you said more than twice that amount you would be right.
I don't know what an (electrical, chemical, industrial, biomedical, environmental, mechanical, software, railroad, etc.) engineer with a Master's degree and 13 years' experience earns. But, even if I did, that's comparing apples to oranges. Engineers are not teachers, and teachers are not engineers. Public employees should not automatically be entitled to the same salaries as employees in the private sector.
Also, full-time engineers in the private sector usually work 12 months out of the year and 8 hours a day, not nine months and 6 1/2 hours a day that teachers are expected to work and do not have all government holidays off to earn that salary.
I do not know what percent of engineers' salaries their employer pays toward their retirement fund or what kind of pension they receive, but taxpayers pay 14% of our teachers' salaries for their retirement fund, and our teachers can retire after 39 years and receive a pension equal to the average of their last three annual salaries every year for the rest of their life--with full health care coverage on top of that!
Another interesting bit of propaganda is your assertion that teachers will receive a salary increase of" a minimum of 10%." I firmly believe this is false.
Truth is not propaganda. I have posted on my home page the sources that back up the truth of my statement along with links that further explain my statement. District officials, the Board Vice-President, the Superintendent, and the Financial Forecasts have all confirmed that the Board expects to pay those increases in FY13.
According to your numbers, a teacher earning $79,000 next year will be earning about $87,000 the following year. The year after, if this 10% increase continues, the salary would be $95,700. So to recap, the average teacher in the Brecksville-Broadview Heights School District will be earning close to $100,000 in two years.
Those are your numbers, not mine. I did not say that the 10% increase would go beyond "the following year." I only referenced FY13.
This is the message that you are sending to the community, and unfortunately the kids in this city will suffer because many people will believe your rhetoric.
According to the Board Policy 0123(A)'s the Board's "first and greatest concern must be the educational welfare of all students attending the public schools."
The Board (twice) approved salary and benefit increases it knew it could not afford. If the Board needs to make cuts in order to pay or maintain those increases, then the Board’s "first and greatest concern" must be to ensure those cuts are not detrimental to our schoolchildren’s education.
Any suffering that our children would or would not have to endure rests solely on the Board--not the voters and not on me. Demanding that a school board be fiscally responsible will be much better for the children and the community as a whole in the long run.
Thank you for your time.
And thank you for your time. I appreciate the fact that you brought your concerns to my attention. I believe that communication between people who hold opposing views is a good thing. I also appreciate that you are willing to make the effort to do what you believe is in the best interests of the schoolchildren.
|