Doggie Dollars and Scents
 
guard duty
hearing of public
*
Hostile Teachers Display Lack of Decorum at Public School Board Meeting
Effort to Muzzle Watchdog Gets Unruly


The May 24, 2010 school board meeting was not a typical meeting. First, it started at 5:30 (for PSO Presidents' Reports) instead of 7:00. Second, the meeting was held at the Brecksville Community Center instead of its usual meeting place: the Education Center. Third, by 7:00, the room was filled to capacity with school employees (of whom, the overwhelming majority were teachers) wearing red shirts.

In the more than five years that I've been watching the Board, I've not seen anything like what I saw at that meeting, nor have I ever been surrounded by so many teachers. As I stood among the teachers (and staff), waiting for a seat to open up, I could sense hostility toward me from a relatively few teachers, and that hostility manifested itself during my public comments to the Board, which you'll see as you continue to read.

The President of the teachers' union, Bonnie Montleone said, during her public comments to the Board, that the teachers (and staff) were there to show their support for the teachers who were recognized that night for achieving Master Teacher status. Last year, there were only a few teachers who showed up to show their support for the teachers who were being recognized as "Master Teachers." Ms. Montleone also said that the teachers (and staff) were also there so that "you can see our loyal staff."
 
Some of the non-teaching staff present were bus drivers who have also shown up at several recent board meetings because of their concern about the busing cuts. I don't know if the President of the union that represents non-teaching staff was there, but if he/she was, he/she didn't publicly make it known.

In comparison to the number of teachers who were at that May 24 meeting, there were very few residents there. One parent said during his public comments that it was difficult for him to address the Board about the busing cuts because the room was filled with so many teachers and staff, and another resident said during her public comments that she felt like she was at a teachers' union meeting.
 
I was the first person to address the Board during the Hearing of the Public portion of the meeting. I was interrupted with undignified grumbling and shouts. Just after I stated my name and address to the Board, Bonnie Montleone, the President of the teachers' union, who apparently wasn't interested in what I had to say, raised her voice and interjected, "Address. Street address" as though she were in charge of the meeting and even though I had already stated my name and address. George Balasko who presided over the meeting had to quiet the room so that I could continue with my comments.

In my comments to the Board, I exposed how the Board is allowing the public to be given false information by allowing Board Vice-President Alan Scheufler to make false or misleading statements to the public about staff reductions--statements that contradict the public record.
 
I was unable to finish what I wanted to say because, as I was concluding my comments, I was interrupted by people around the room (including teachers and the President of the teachers' union, Bonnie Montleone) with loud grumbles and shouts that my 3 minute time limit was up. Those outbursts received a reprimand by Board member, David Tryon.

During the numerous times that I have publicly addressed the Board over the past five years, I have never before seen so many members of the public show such an undignified lack of self-restraint.  It was especially unbecoming for those supposedly representing "our loyal staff" to display this lack of decorum at a public school board meeting. 

As a parent, a resident, a taxpayer, and the self-appointed school board watchdog, I was exposing the fact that our school board is allowing the public to be given false information about staff reductions. I was (twice) interrupted by a few teachers who were unable to exercise self-restraint and they were publicly reprimanded for it.
 
If the hostility of those few teachers toward me stems from my website, then that hostility is really a hostility toward the free and open exchange of ideas. It is hostility toward someone who holds a viewpoint different from their own, someone who believes that the Board should exercise fiscal discipline instead of irresponsibly approving increases that the District cannot afford, someone who believes that if the Board must choose between the best interests of the teachers and the best interests of the students, the Board should choose the best interest of the students.  If the hostility stems from my opposition to the levy, then their hostility extends to the majority of the taxpayers in this community who pay their wages and voted the levy down.


hearing of public
 
guard duty
Doggie Dollars and Scents